State Farm® Insurance Agent Michael Lybarger
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Katie Knipp
June 24, 2026
"Michael and his staff have always gone above and beyond for us anytime we’ve needed anything. They’ve been amazing to work with."
"We are grateful for your 5-star review, Katie! Thanks for taking a moment to share your positive rating of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in Ontario . "
arbor “arbor”
June 23, 2026
"pays for my car insurance"
"Thanks so much for the amazing review, arbor! We really appreciate your support here in Ontario . If you ever have any questions or need insurance assistance in the future, we are just a message away!"
shannon young
June 23, 2026
"Best insurance agent there ever was"
"Thank you so much for the 5-stars, shannon! We really appreciate your feedback and are always here to help with any insurance needs you have. Feel free to reach out to us here on State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team anytime."
Beth Shambaugh
June 23, 2026
"Expressed issues with him I was having with customer service with a claim I had filed he got right on the phone contacted customer service explained my issue and had my problem resolved thanks so much for fast courteous customer service #myagentisbetterthanyours"
Benjamin May
June 23, 2026
"Excellent customer service. Excellent response. Great price. Easy switching from other provider. I would rate this a 4.95 out of 5 only cause of that goofy Michael Lybarger guy. He’s a cool dude though so buy some insurance from him. 😂"
"Wow, thank you for the amazing 5-star review! It means a lot to us here in Ontario to know that you had such a wonderful experience with us here on State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team."
Carolina Lukkarila
June 22, 2026
"I’ll keep it short since I can’t reply to the lie he gave, but I would discourage business with this group. We’ve had a claim going since December that has been horrible to resolve / get responses or calls back from anyone with any excuse given. Mistakes made not once but twice despite consistent attempts to communicate with them. We would appreciate any sort of update regarding anything happening on our claim.
Their reply is once again a lie: we have documentation of multiple instances of where they did not return our call. The check that was “overnighted” FOUR WEEKS AGO still hasn’t even been issued! But you’re right, nobody is lying! Even though we have that on voicemail, from May. It’s June.. did we lie or? Or where you were in a meeting last week but could reply to the Google review but NEVER call back? Another lie. It’s been months of this check “being in the mail.” If that’s not a lie, it’s certainly not the truth.. They now refuse to talk to my husband and sent a letter threatening to drop us because we made two claims more than six months apart in two separate years. I will be taking this all over social media at this point, as it seems to be the only way to get a response out of you. And Michael, you have never spoken to ME one time. So again, another lie. Our claim did not replace what was owed, WE HAVE NEVER GOTTEN A CHECK!!! So yes, you’re right, it’s not an acceptable way to conduct business, thanks for acknowledging that."
"Hello again! To make something perfectly clear nobody from my office has never lied to anyone. That is not an acceptable way to conduct business. I truly wish you claim would have went smoother, as there were some circumstances outside of my offices control, as well as State Farms. Your claim did pay to replace what was owed. To say we were not transparent in communicating seems off base as well. Multiple times I spoke with you after hours on my personal phone and put you on my list of people I would speak to right away. I completely acknowledge this could have went a lot smoother, and I passed along my concerns on your behalf. "
Kathleen Wallace
June 22, 2026
"Shonna was great to work with. She answered all of our questions and helped us save thousands of dollars by switching companies. It was such an easy process. You won’t be disappointed if you work with Shonna."
"Thank you for the fantastic review, Kathleen! We are always here to help with your insurance needs here in Ontario . "
Erik Wybe
June 18, 2026
"Super excited dropped my insurance by 75 percent . Awsome service thank you"
"We appreciate your review, Erik. We are so happy that you had such a wonderful experience with State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in Ontario ! "
Bill C
June 17, 2026
"Promptly answered all of my questions and was able to set up a great policy!"
"Bill, thank you for your kind review. We deeply appreciate your feedback of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in our Ontario office. "
Jenny Brewer
May 4, 2026
"The best"
"Thanks for the impressive review! We are thrilled to hear you had a wonderful experience with State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in Ontario . "
Amber Mansfield
April 30, 2026
"Michael Lybarger is very rude and disrespectful not helpful at all whatsoever! I wanted to change agents only because I wanted to switch to the town where I was living and he told me to do it on the app knowing good and well you cannot do it over the app so I asked him what what do I click on or look under to make that change he told me to “figure it out”! Do not use this so call man as your agent."
"We wish you and your family the best of luck with your future endeavors. "
Brandy Awbrey
April 29, 2026
"Every time I’ve needed to call, the staff are always courteous, willing to go out of the way to assist, & most of all patient when answering questions. Never, ever had a bad experience with this agency. You can feel the genuine care here. Will not go anywhere else!"
"Brandy, thank you for your wonderful review of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team!"
stephanie holley
April 27, 2026
"Love love love everyone I’ve worked with at the office! They’re all so kind and helpful. Rachel in the office is super sweet and went above and beyond to make sure I understood my policy. Looking for insurance, I would definitely call these guys!"
"Thank you for the wonderful 5-star review! We are so happy you had a wonderful experience with us here at State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team. If you ever need anything down the road, do not hesitate to reach out—we would love to help!"
Ashley Risner
April 22, 2026
"Great experience! I received help from the get-go and never once felt like I didn’t have my questions/concerns addressed. I highly recommend for any insurance needs!"
"Ashley, it is a pleasure to hear what a wonderful experience you have had with State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team!"
Matthias Stewart
April 17, 2026
"Highly recommend Michael Lybarger and his State Farm team. They were professional, responsive, and very efficient throughout the entire process. They took the time to carefully review our current home and auto policies, explain coverage options clearly, and make sure we were properly protected rather than just chasing a lower price. In the end, they helped us improve key areas of coverage while also saving us a meaningful amount of money. Great experience from start to finish and excellent customer care."
"Matthias, thank you for your kind review. We deeply appreciate your feedback of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in our Ontario office. "
joshua Ryoo
April 11, 2026
"Great people to do business with."
"Thanks for the 5-stars! We appreciate your feedback and support here on State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team. "
Trevor Lewis
April 6, 2026
"They helped me with everything I needed gave me a great price answered all my questions help me so much 10/10"
"Thank you for the amazing review, Trevor! It is truly the goal of our team to exceed expectations when it comes to all insurance needs."
Ciera Cyrus
March 24, 2026
"Rachel is an absolute gem. She is so polite and professional. Every time I have a question or need help with my policy she is on the ball! If she has to call me back it's always very quick and has all the information ready for me. Honestly calling in to this office is one of the only phone calls I don't dread."
"Ciera, thank you for your kind review. We deeply appreciate your feedback of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in our Ontario office. "
Katherine Webb
March 3, 2026
"Michael and his team are very knowledgeable and helped save my family tons of money! They are easy to communicate with and truly want what’s best for their clients."
"Thanks for the impressive review! We genuinely appreciate you taking the time to leave this great feedback for us here on State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team. "
Tavion Harris
March 2, 2026
"Jill was AWESOME. She helped me and listened to my needs and assisted in a major way!"
"Thanks for the impressive review! We genuinely appreciate you taking the time to leave this great feedback for us here on State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team. "
Carla Jackson
February 28, 2026
"Demi was amazing I would highly recommend her. She took the time to get all of the information that I asked for and I could not have asked for a better person to have been able to work on my case.."
"We are grateful for your 5-star review, Carla! Thanks for taking a moment to share your positive rating of State Farm Agent Michael Lybarger’s Team here in Ontario . "
Gregory Spayde
February 24, 2026
"Demi at Michael Lybarger State Farm office did a fantastic job and we are very happy with everything. She went above and beyond....great service excellent job 5 stars"
Madison Phillips
February 24, 2026
"Very polite and helpful people !"
JokurAtkinson
February 24, 2026
"Have been using him for years and have always had a great experience."
Susan Spayde
February 21, 2026
"We worked with Demi and she was wonderful, we changed all of our insurance, 🚗 cars, motorcycle 🏍 and house 🏠. She did an absolutely fantastic job,we are very happy that we changed our insurance over to state farm."